Radical Middle Newsletter
Idealism Without Illusions

 

ABOUT THE  NEWS- LETTER

HOME

Site Map

E-mail the Editor

ARCHIVES:

Access All Mark Satin Articles, 2005- 2009

Access All Mark Satin Articles, 1999- 2004

Access John Avlon Archive, 2004-2006

Satin's 10 Best Writings Ever

RADICAL MIDDLE, THE BOOK:

Book's Home Page

Book's Preface

Author's Publicity Schedule

OUR  CONGRES- SIONAL SCORECARDS:

109th and 110th Congresses (2005-08)

108th Congress (2003 & 2004)

107th Congress (2001 & 2002)

OUR POLITICAL BOOK AWARD WINNERS:

1980 - 2009, Complete

RESPONSES FROM  OTHERS:

Feisty E-mails to the Editor, 2008 - 2009

Feisty E-mails to the Editor, 2007

Feisty E-mails to the Editor, 2006

Feisty E-mails to the Editor, 2005

Feisty Letters to the Editor, 2002-04

Feisty Letters to the Editor, 1999-2001

WHO WE ARE:

About the Editor (In-House Version)

About the Editor (By Marilyn Ferguson)

About Our Wonderful Pledgers

About Our Board of Advisors

About Our Sponsor, the Center for Visionary  Law

 

May 15, 2006 -- Mark Satin, Editor

“Don’t blame me,
I voted for Bartlet!”

by John Avlon

At a time when the TV show "American Idol" garners greater levels of voter participation than actual American elections, there is reason to question whether the entertainment industry adds much of civic value to our society.

But viewers of NBC's "The West Wing," which was taken off the air after seven seasons last night, know there is a positive counter-example, making the show's demise all the sadder.

Web sites devoted to the show detail the life and times of President Josiah Bartlet's fictional administration. Boosters who once printed "Don't blame me, I voted for Bartlet" bumper stickers are now posting depressive paragraphs on blogs, pondering life after "The West Wing."

Most political dramas do not provoke this outpouring of affection. For that matter, most television shows do not deserve mention on the editorial page of a newspaper, but "The West Wing" has always been different.

It inspired

Since it appeared in 1999, during the drifting last years of the Clinton administration, the show presented an idealistic and witty take on U.S. politics to the American people.

Martin Sheen played President Bartlet, a stubborn but principled New Englander who served as the show's imperfect moral anchor. Never syrupy, but nonetheless free from spin, hypocrisy, and craven instincts, President Bartlet symbolized the better angels of our nature. Hungry for evident integrity from public officials, people responded.

Just as medical school applications surged after the initial success of the television show "ER," "The West Wing" inspired many young people in the Clinton and Bush era to believe that public service could be a noble and exciting calling. Fiction carried forward a sense of civic purpose where reality sometimes failed to inspire.

When I worked at New York’s City Hall, "West Wing" videotapes would be passed around among different staffers the day after the show aired. We joked that we needed to work on our witty banter to rise to the level of the televised cast.

It educated

In the rapid-fire scripts penned by the show's creator, Aaron Sorkin, there were not only the obligatory personal dramas but also useful lessons in political and governmental problem-solving. Issues that might have lain dormant on Page A24 of the newspaper were all of a sudden thrust into prime time.

It educated while also entertaining, boosting the intellectual quality of water cooler conversations across the country. There were detailed campaign strategies, endless conflicts in the Middle East, coups in Haiti, immigration debates, a debunking of WTO protests, and illegally ordered assassinations of terrorist-sponsor-state leaders.

In one memorable episode, President Bartlet employed a unique interpretation of the Antiquities Act to set aside a piece of national park land and save it from drilling.

The show also embraced the mechanics of constitutional crises, from the resignation of the vice president under a sex scandal to a temporary assumption of presidential powers by the Speaker of the House.

It had class

Some episodes had the resonance of fine film.

The epic episode "Two Cathedrals" drove far off the normal TV trail with President Bartlet cursing at God in Latin while stubbing a cigarette out on the floor of the National Cathedral. He is subsequently visited by the ghost of his former secretary, who coaches him through a crisis of personal and political faith as he admits that he lied to the American people and now faces a seemingly impossible re-election without the support of his wife.

The closing scene was accompanied the Dire Straits' song "Brothers in Arms,” and it is something that I still watch for courage when times get tough. "The West Wing" inspires that kind of talismanic loyalty and the best of it bears repeated viewing.

Recent ups and downs

In recent years, with Aaron Sorkin gone, the show took on a more formulaic television drama feel, sort of "ER" in the White House, responding to crises without ever reaching the same level of poetry that had been so consistent throughout the first and second season.

But in this last year, with the presidential race going on to succeed President Bartlet, the show regained its pacing as it ran through the difficult logistics of a presidential campaign that placed a moderate Republican against a Democratic dark horse. The season featured a live, real-time presidential debate on policy issues that was at least as substantive as anything in 2004.

Tragedy struck the show last December, as John Spencer, the actor who played the craggy but beloved chief of staff and vice-presidential candidate Leo McGarry, died of a heart attack in real life after suffering one on screen the previous season. Last month on the show, his character died on Election Day. It is a season of endings, even as new beginnings are hinted towards.

Radical-middle sendoff

But "The West Wing" had one final penetrating message for the American people which -- if it was heard -- placed them well ahead of the Beltway crowd.

In one of the final episodes, the victorious Democratic presidential candidate offered to make his vanquished foe Secretary of State to form a bipartisan unity government.

By envisioning an alternative to Washington's pervasive polarization, that episode allowed "The West Wing" to prove one final time that popular culture can communicate big ideas more convincingly than a thousand political action committees.

//////////

John Avlon, b. 1973, worked on Bill Clinton's re-election campaign, then worked for Mayor Giuliani from 1997-2001, starting out as an advance man and ending up as chief speechwriter.  He is the author of Independent Nation (Crown / Random House, pbk. 2005).

ABOUT THE RADICAL MIDDLE CONCEPT

WHY "Radical Middle"?

WIKIPEDIA Weighs In

50 Thinkers and Activists DESCRIBE the Radical Middle 

50 Best Radical Middle BOOKS of the '00s

GREAT RADICAL MIDDLE  GROUPS AND BLOGS:

100 Great Radical Centrist GROUPS and  Organizations

25 Great Radical Centrist BLOGS

SOME PRIOR RADICAL MIDDLE INITIATIVES:

Generational Equity and Communitarian platforms 1990s

First U.S. Green Party gatherings, 1987 - 1990

Green Party's "Ten Key Values" statement, 1984

New World Alliance, 1979 - 1983

PDF of  the Alliance's "Transformation Platform," 1981

SOME RADICAL MIDDLE LESSONS:

What the Draft Resistance Movement Taught Me

What the Civil Rights Movement Taught Me

SOME PRIOR  WRITINGS BY MARK SATIN:

New Options Newsletter, 1984-1992 (includes back issue PDFs!)

New Age Politics: Healing Self and Society, 1976,  1978 (includes 1976 text PDF!)

OTHER
PRIOR   RADICAL MIDDLE TEXTS:

50 Best "Third Way" Books of the 1990s

25 Best "Transformational" Books of the 1980s

25 Best "New Age Politics" Books of the 1970s

NOT JUST RADICAL MIDDLE:

10 Best U.S. Political NOVELS

50 Current Political IDEOLOGIES

50 Current Political  MANIFESTOS